ProfileSquawkBlogPhotosBlogLists Tools Help

Blog


    June 26

    From Whistleblower To Witness

    The SEC lawyer who is at the center of an investigation into possible insider trading at the prominent hedge fund Pequot Capital has agreed to appear as at witness during Senate Judiciary Committee hearings that are focusing on the secretive hedge-fund business, CNBC has learned.

             Former SEC attorney Gary J. Aguirre, (pronounced a-GEER-ray) headed SEC's investigation and then criticized the agency's handling of the case after the commission fired him. Aguirre has agreed to testify in the hearings, scheduled to take place Wednesday in Washington, according to a preliminary witness list obtained by CNBC and a person with knowledge of the committee's activities. Other witnesses include a representative of the Department of Justice as well as Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal, the chief law enforcement official of the state where most hedge funds reside. Committee Chairman Arlen Specter may also ask a representative of the SEC to appear at the hearings.

           Aguirre's testimony would mark his first public comments since

    news of a letter he sent members of Congress leaked last week that

    rocked the massive and growing hedge-fund business. In an 18 page

    letter, Aguirre alleges that he was fired from the SEC as he was

    investigating possible insider trading violations at Pequot and

    preparing to depose Morgan Stanley CEO John Mack as a witness. Before taking the Morgan Stanley post, Mack was the vice chairman of the hedge fund, but more importantly for the investigation, he was the CEO of Credit Suisse when the firm was serving as a banker in a deal that has come under scrutiny during Aguirre's insider trading probe. Both Pequot and officials at Morgan Stanley say they've done nothing wrong.

          According to people with knowledge of the committee's activities, Specter believes Aguirre could provide what has since been missing from the witness list as he gears up for the hearings: A genuine, inside look into the secretive world of hedge funds and some indication if the business needs closer scrutiny from regulators at the SEC and the Department of Justice.

    People with knowledge of Specter's activities say the Senator may also use the hearings as a springboard to introduce legislation that would increase hedge fund regulation. Just last week a federal appeals court says the SEC doesn't have the authority to enhance its regulation of the hedge fund business.

         All the congressional activity won't be good news for the hedge

    fund business, which for years operated on the periphery of Wall Street, catering to the super rich. More recently, hedge funds

    have grown in popularity with more mainstream investors, and as a

    result, they've caught the eye of regulators.

         CNBC has learned that the committee's interest in the hedge fund business stemmed in large part from the complaints of Overstock.com's CEO Patrick Byrne, who convinced Utah senator Orin Hatch, a ranking member of the judiciary committee, to take a

    close look at hedge funds, short selling and the use of research to drive down stock prices. Overstock is located in Utah, and Byrne has waged a  public campaign attacking short sellers for using potentially illegal tactics to drive the stock.

         But Specter, the committee chairman, chose not to focus on

    Overstock and include Byrne as a witness because he feared the

    hearings would turn into a spectacle given some of Byrne's recent

    comments, and instead began to focus on larger issues involving hedge funds, namely whether the Justice Department and other regulators like the SEC has done enough to crack down on hedge-fund fraud.

          People with knowledge of the committee's activities say he

    believes Aguirre would make a perfect witness given his inside

    knowledge of both hedge funds and regulatory attempts top crack downon the business. These people also say that Specter and the committee will examine why Aguirre was fired.

     

    Charles Gasparino - CNBC

    Comments (3)

    Please wait...
    Sorry, the comment you entered is too long. Please shorten it.
    You didn't enter anything. Please try again.
    Sorry, we can't add your comment right now. Please try again later.
    To add a comment, you need permission from your parent. Ask for permission
    Your parent has turned off comments.
    Sorry, we can't delete your comment right now. Please try again later.
    You've exceeded the maximum number of comments that can be left in one day. Please try again in 24 hours.
    Your account has had the ability to leave comments disabled because our systems indicate that you may be spamming other users. If you believe that your account has been disabled in error please contact Windows Live support.
    Complete the security check below to finish leaving your comment.
    The characters you type in the security check must match the characters in the picture or audio.
    Comments have been turned off on this page.
    Picture of Anonymous
    Rex wrote:
    I agree.  The Feds wouldn't know what to do with Hedge Funds.
    June 29
    Picture of Anonymous
    Duke Longwell wrote:

    The Hedge Fund Problem

     

    By: Duke Longwell

     

    The problem with Hedge Funds is not in the managers but in the news coverage and with the regulators.  The news makes them look like thieves and cheaters, and the regulators tell them they can’t defend themselves.

    I work with a Hedge Fund of Funds, and I have yet to yield to the so-called secretive nature of the hedge fund industry.  For the years I have been doing Due Diligence on this secretive business I have never been denied access to a manager.  I don’t believe that the bad press that is being tossed around about hedge funds is at all true.  If Pequot Capital, did anything wrong and it was being covered up by the SEC this isn’t a hedge fund problem it is an SEC problem.  Yes there are instances where hedge fund managers do commit fraud, Bayou Capital and Wood River, but simply going to see the manager and asking to see capital account statements from the Prime Broker, which every hedge fund should have, not an Ameritrade account, if they can’t produce them, or if they do and there is less than what they say they have under management DON’T invest with them.  You shouldn’t invest in a stock you don’t research and you don’t buy a car you haven’t test driven, so why do you throw money at a hedge fund manager who you don’t research. 

    There are 20 managers that the FOF has in it, and we receive a prime broker statement from the prime broker for each manager, I wouldn’t exactly call that secretive.  For our investors they trust that we are doing everything in our power to make sure that the manager is not going to commit fraud, or has not already.  These instances such as Canary, Pequot and SAC are not the norm for this industry.  Just because Dennis Kozlowski throws a party in Sardinia it doesn’t mean that every CEO in Corporate America is going to do the same thing.   

    The regulation of Hedge Funds is fine in my book.  Make them register, make them subject to SEC audits, it will make my job easier, but don’t give them the ability to opt out of registration, by allowing them to “lock-up” partners capital for two or more years which just increases the risk of something happening to that fund as I have seen in the past.  By a partner not being able to leave it just creates more of a chance for ponzi schemes, because you know what the partners’ redemption times are.  Also the “lock-up” period doesn’t allow you to leave when the so-called death spiral begins.  When hedge funds tend to “Blow-up” the fund begins to lose tens of percentage points per month, with a lock-up you can’t get out until the death spiral is over and you have lost well in excess of 50% of your capital.  Before you go chastising hedge funds, you need to look at the investor who says “Jim Cramer was talking about Pepsi I want to buy that” because that is the amount of research that those investors are going to do on hedge funds.

    June 28
    Picture of Anonymous
    Eamon Strait wrote:
    Political hearings fall short most often, as this one will.  Using a disgruntled ex-employee to describe the inner workings of an indistry that his agency was not authorized to regulate won't go far.  The SEC tried the variable life insurance industry and failed because they didn't understand the insurance element.  They have no chance with hedge funds.
    June 27

    Trackbacks

    Weblogs that reference this entry
    • None